WWIM-Data-2018-1
EXPERT MEETING ON CLIMATE DATA MODERNISATION
KNMI
De Bilt
The Netherlands
16-18 April 2018
1. AICH, Valentin (WMO/GCOS) Junior Science Office
2. BADDOUR, Omar (WMO) Chief, Data Management Applications Division
3. BERGERON, Cedric (ECMWF) Copernicus
4. BEROD, Dominique (WMO) Chief of Hydrology Division
5. BUSSELBERG, Thornsten (WIS/Germany)
6. CAZENAVE, Anny (Sea Level Expert/Toulouse)
7. DUNN, Robert (Met Office/Hadley Center) Climate Scientist
8. GALLAHER, David (NSIDC) Senior Associate Scientist and Manager of Technical Services
9. GATES, Lydia (DWD/Germany) Marine Data Expert
10.LIEF, Christina (CCl-IPET-CDMP/France) Physical Scientist
11.MILAN, Anna (NOAA/NCEI) Metadata and data standard Expert
12.PENG, Ge (CICS-NC, NOAA/NCEI) Research Scholar/Maturity Matrix Expert
13.ROBERTS, Kate (BOM) Expert in academic libraries, data management and standards
14.SIEGMUND, Peter (KNMI) Climate Researcher
15.VERVER, Ge (KNMI) Climate Scientist with expertise in climate extremes
16.WRIGHT, William (BOM) Senior Meteorologist
17.ZIESE, Markus (DWD) Expert on Climate Indices and precipitation data
Information on the meeting is posted at: http://www.wmo.int/pages/prog/wcp/ccl/opace/opace1/meetings/ET-CDM-2018.php
08:30-9:00 Welcome/Introductions
09:00-9:20 Outcomes of the International Workshop (Omar Baddour)
09:20-9:40 Project on climate data-sets (William Wright)
09:40-10:00 Ad hoc Working Group, TOR and thematic focus (Christina Lief)
10:00-10:30 Break
10:30-11:00 Maturity Models and need for WMO Maturity Matrix Convergence Model (Peter Siegmund)
11:00-11:30 Need for Prominent Discovery and the use of WIS infrastructure (Kate Roberts/Thornsten
Busselberg)
11:30-12:00 What Metadata are needed, and Citation issues (Kate Roberts)
12:00-13:00 Lunch
13:00- 17:30 Session-II: Available datasets and a way-forward (Session chair: William Wright)
13:00-13:15 Dataset Issues: Robert Dunn
1) 13:15-13:30 Status of ECV and process of evaluation of ECV datasets (GCOS perspective): Valentin Aich
2) 13:30-13:45 Climate Indices: Peter Siegmund
3) 13:45-14:00 Temperature data: Robert Dunn
4) 14:00-14:15 Precipitation data: Markus Ziese
5) 14:15-14:30 Sea Level data: Anny Cazenave (presented by Christina Lief)
14:30-15:00 Break
6) 15:00-15:15 Cryosphere data: David Gallaher
7) 15:15-15:30 Hydrology data, status and quality process: Dominique Berod
8) 15:30-15:45 Marine data: Lydia Gates
9) 15:45-16:00 Copernicus data: Cedric Bergeron
16:00-16:30 Summary/Comments
16:30-16:50 Presentation of Maturity models (Ge Peng)
16:50-17:10 Current Status of the Maturity Matrix Convergence Model (William Wright)
17:10-17:30 A way forward for prominent discovery for the WMO Data Catalog of High-quality Climate Data (Anna
Milan)
19:00 group dinner at Restaurant De Griffel, Hessenweg 117 De Bilt (~400 m from KNMI)
08:30 – 17:30 (Breaks 10:00-10:30 & 16:00-16:30 + Lunch 12:00-13:00 Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal (100 m from
KNMI))
- 8:30-9:00 Group selection and TOR presentations meeting in Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 9:00-11:30 BOG A, B, C meetings
- 11:30-12:00 Feedback from groups Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
Lunch 12:00-13:00 Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 13:00-13:30 Feedback from groups resumed Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 13:30-16:00 BOG A,B,C meetings
Break 16:00-16:30 Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 16:00-17:30 BOG A,B,C meetings
Breakout Group Assignment:
- BOG A: Data Catalog of High-quality Climate Data (Peter Siegmund) Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal (100 m from
KNMI)
SIEGMUND, Peter (KNMI) Lead
BEROD, Dominique (WMO)
DUNN, Robert (Met Office)
GALLAHER, David (NSIDC)
GATES, Lydia (DWD/JCOMM)
LIEF, Christina (CCl-IPET-CDMP)
ZIESE, Markus (DWD/GPCC)
- BOG B: WMO Maturity Matrix Convergence Model (Ge Peng) Location: KNMI, A1.27
PENG, Ge (CICS-NC, NOAA/NCEI) Lead
BADDOUR, Omar (WMO)
AICH, Valentin (WMO/GCOS)
WRIGHT, William (BOM)
- BOG C: Discovery and Access for the WMO Data Catalog of High-quality Climate Data (Anna Milan) Location:
KNMI, A2.28
MILAN, Anna (NOAA/NCEI) Lead
ROBERTS, Kate (BOM)
BUSSELBERG, Thorsten (DWD/WIS)
BERGERON, Cedric (ECMWF)
08:30-12:00 Session-IV (Break 10:00-10:30)(Session chair: Christina Lief/Rapporteur: Omar Baddour)
- 8:30-8:45 Organizational meeting
- 8:45-10:00 Maturity Matrix group B meeting - Complete Matrix - Location: room KNMI A2.28
- 8:45-10:00 Data Catalog Group A + WIS Group C meeting - Reconcile Catalog requirements - Location: Lanskyzaal
Break 10:00-10:30
- 10:30-12:00 BOG A,B,C Reports and finalization
Lunch 12:00-13:00
- 13:00-16:30 Session-V Recommendations on next steps and implementations (Finalize Catalog with MM for each datasets, and Finalize data/metadata requirements DCPC and GISC)
Utrechtseweg 297
3731 GA De Bilt
The Netherlands
Fahrenheitzaal (KNMI, main building, ground floor)
Tuesday 17 April
BOG A on Data Catalog: AMLS, Lanskyzaal (100 m from KNMI)
BOG B on Maturity Matrix: A1.27 (KNMI main building, 1st floor)
BOG C on Discovery&Access: A2.28 (KNMI main building, 2nd floor)
Breaks, Lunch: AMLS, Lanskyzaal
Wednesday 18 April
AMLS, Lanskyzaal
AMLC: ring door bell
e-mail: siegmund@knmi.nl
tel. + 31 30 2206 798
mobile: + 31 6 45832179 (within Netherlands: 06-45832179)
-Other hotels are in Utrecht city. The https://www.mitland.nl/ is a good second choice, relatively close
(about 3 km) to KNMI, with good bus connection to KNMI.
-If people want to stay in Utrecht city centre, there are many hotels that can be found on the Internet.
travel time)
- From Utrecht Central Station to KNMI or hotel Biltsche Hoek (15’ travel time): bus 50, 51, 52, 53, or 74,
leave at stop Tunneltje De Bilt; or take a taxi.
KNMI
De Bilt
The Netherlands
16-18 April 2018
Participants:
1. AICH, Valentin (WMO/GCOS) Junior Science Office
2. BADDOUR, Omar (WMO) Chief, Data Management Applications Division
3. BERGERON, Cedric (ECMWF) Copernicus
4. BEROD, Dominique (WMO) Chief of Hydrology Division
5. BUSSELBERG, Thornsten (WIS/Germany)
6. CAZENAVE, Anny (Sea Level Expert/Toulouse)
7. DUNN, Robert (Met Office/Hadley Center) Climate Scientist
8. GALLAHER, David (NSIDC) Senior Associate Scientist and Manager of Technical Services
9. GATES, Lydia (DWD/Germany) Marine Data Expert
10.LIEF, Christina (CCl-IPET-CDMP/France) Physical Scientist
11.MILAN, Anna (NOAA/NCEI) Metadata and data standard Expert
12.PENG, Ge (CICS-NC, NOAA/NCEI) Research Scholar/Maturity Matrix Expert
13.ROBERTS, Kate (BOM) Expert in academic libraries, data management and standards
14.SIEGMUND, Peter (KNMI) Climate Researcher
15.VERVER, Ge (KNMI) Climate Scientist with expertise in climate extremes
16.WRIGHT, William (BOM) Senior Meteorologist
17.ZIESE, Markus (DWD) Expert on Climate Indices and precipitation data
Information on the meeting is posted at: http://www.wmo.int/pages/prog/wcp/ccl/opace/opace1/meetings/ET-CDM-2018.php
PROGRAMME:
Day-1. Plenary
08:30-12:00 Session-I: Setting the Stage (Session chair: Peter Siegmund)08:30-9:00 Welcome/Introductions
09:00-9:20 Outcomes of the International Workshop (Omar Baddour)
09:20-9:40 Project on climate data-sets (William Wright)
09:40-10:00 Ad hoc Working Group, TOR and thematic focus (Christina Lief)
10:00-10:30 Break
10:30-11:00 Maturity Models and need for WMO Maturity Matrix Convergence Model (Peter Siegmund)
11:00-11:30 Need for Prominent Discovery and the use of WIS infrastructure (Kate Roberts/Thornsten
Busselberg)
11:30-12:00 What Metadata are needed, and Citation issues (Kate Roberts)
12:00-13:00 Lunch
13:00- 17:30 Session-II: Available datasets and a way-forward (Session chair: William Wright)
13:00-13:15 Dataset Issues: Robert Dunn
1) 13:15-13:30 Status of ECV and process of evaluation of ECV datasets (GCOS perspective): Valentin Aich
2) 13:30-13:45 Climate Indices: Peter Siegmund
3) 13:45-14:00 Temperature data: Robert Dunn
4) 14:00-14:15 Precipitation data: Markus Ziese
5) 14:15-14:30 Sea Level data: Anny Cazenave (presented by Christina Lief)
14:30-15:00 Break
6) 15:00-15:15 Cryosphere data: David Gallaher
7) 15:15-15:30 Hydrology data, status and quality process: Dominique Berod
8) 15:30-15:45 Marine data: Lydia Gates
9) 15:45-16:00 Copernicus data: Cedric Bergeron
16:00-16:30 Summary/Comments
16:30-16:50 Presentation of Maturity models (Ge Peng)
16:50-17:10 Current Status of the Maturity Matrix Convergence Model (William Wright)
17:10-17:30 A way forward for prominent discovery for the WMO Data Catalog of High-quality Climate Data (Anna
Milan)
19:00 group dinner at Restaurant De Griffel, Hessenweg 117 De Bilt (~400 m from KNMI)
Day-2. Breakout Working Groups
Session-III08:30 – 17:30 (Breaks 10:00-10:30 & 16:00-16:30 + Lunch 12:00-13:00 Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal (100 m from
KNMI))
- 8:30-9:00 Group selection and TOR presentations meeting in Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 9:00-11:30 BOG A, B, C meetings
- 11:30-12:00 Feedback from groups Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
Lunch 12:00-13:00 Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 13:00-13:30 Feedback from groups resumed Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 13:30-16:00 BOG A,B,C meetings
Break 16:00-16:30 Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal
- 16:00-17:30 BOG A,B,C meetings
Breakout Group Assignment:
- BOG A: Data Catalog of High-quality Climate Data (Peter Siegmund) Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal (100 m from
KNMI)
SIEGMUND, Peter (KNMI) Lead
BEROD, Dominique (WMO)
DUNN, Robert (Met Office)
GALLAHER, David (NSIDC)
GATES, Lydia (DWD/JCOMM)
LIEF, Christina (CCl-IPET-CDMP)
ZIESE, Markus (DWD/GPCC)
- BOG B: WMO Maturity Matrix Convergence Model (Ge Peng) Location: KNMI, A1.27
PENG, Ge (CICS-NC, NOAA/NCEI) Lead
BADDOUR, Omar (WMO)
AICH, Valentin (WMO/GCOS)
WRIGHT, William (BOM)
- BOG C: Discovery and Access for the WMO Data Catalog of High-quality Climate Data (Anna Milan) Location:
KNMI, A2.28
MILAN, Anna (NOAA/NCEI) Lead
ROBERTS, Kate (BOM)
BUSSELBERG, Thorsten (DWD/WIS)
BERGERON, Cedric (ECMWF)
DAY-3. Plenary
Location: AMLC, Lanskyzaal (100 m from KNMI)08:30-12:00 Session-IV (Break 10:00-10:30)(Session chair: Christina Lief/Rapporteur: Omar Baddour)
- 8:30-8:45 Organizational meeting
- 8:45-10:00 Maturity Matrix group B meeting - Complete Matrix - Location: room KNMI A2.28
- 8:45-10:00 Data Catalog Group A + WIS Group C meeting - Reconcile Catalog requirements - Location: Lanskyzaal
Break 10:00-10:30
- 10:30-12:00 BOG A,B,C Reports and finalization
Lunch 12:00-13:00
- 13:00-16:30 Session-V Recommendations on next steps and implementations (Finalize Catalog with MM for each datasets, and Finalize data/metadata requirements DCPC and GISC)
Meeting documents
File Gallery: WWIM-Data-2018-1
| ID | T | Name | Size | Last Modified | Hits |
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
4184 |  |
Baddour Outcome Of The WMO International Workshop |
1.01 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 103 |
|
|
|
4198 | |
Baddour WMO WORKSHOP ON INFORMATION MANAGEMENT OUTCOMES OUTCOMES OF THE WMO WORKSHOP ON INFORMATION MANAGEMENT |
1,001.43 KB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 100 |
|
|
|
4166 | |
Berod Hydrological Data |
2.00 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 120 |
|
|
|
4216 |  |
BOG A On Data Catalog Of High Quality Climate Data BOG A: TOR HQ datasets |
15.91 KB | Tue 17 of Apr, 2018 | 108 |
|
|
|
4226 | |
BOG C Amilan BOG C |
17.86 KB | Wed 18 of Apr, 2018 | 104 |
|
|
|
4248 | |
BOG C Amilan FINAL |
16.72 KB | Wed 18 of Apr, 2018 | 100 |
|
|
|
4182 | |
Busselberg WMO Information System (WIS) V4 |
5.19 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 119 |
|
|
|
4096 | |
Cazenave Sea Level Data Status |
5.49 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 116 |
|
|
|
4178 | |
Copernicus Climate Change Service Climate Data Store |
37.71 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 114 |
|
|
|
4214 | |
Draft List Of GCOS ECV Data Sources Draft list of GCOS ECV data sources |
22.45 KB | Tue 17 of Apr, 2018 | 96 |
|
|
|
4164 | |
Dunn Dataset Issues Dataset issues learned from last time |
3.82 MB | Thu 12 of Apr, 2018 | 97 |
|
|
|
4162 | |
Dunn Temperature Data Temperature dataset overview |
4.19 MB | Thu 12 of Apr, 2018 | 101 |
|
|
|
4210 | |
Gates DeBilt 2018 Marine Data 2 Kopie Marine Data Sets |
7.37 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 104 |
|
|
|
4168 |  |
GCOS ECV Data Data Sources for ECV |
1.86 MB | Fri 13 of Apr, 2018 | 104 |
|
|
|
4224 | |
Lief Ad Hoc Expert Working Group |
919.03 KB | Tue 17 of Apr, 2018 | 101 |
|
|
|
4232 | |
List Of Data Catalog Datasets |
16.67 KB | Wed 18 of Apr, 2018 | 101 |
|
|
|
4244 | |
Peng BOG B Report R3 BOG B Report |
303.68 KB | Wed 18 of Apr, 2018 | 98 |
|
|
|
4172 | |
Peng Maturity Models V2 Current approaches for assessing maturity of individual Earth Science Datasets |
18.04 MB | Sun 15 of Apr, 2018 | 105 |
|
|
|
4212 | |
Peng TOR BOG B BOG B TOR & Discussion Slides |
9.20 MB | Tue 17 of Apr, 2018 | 109 |
|
|
|
4170 | |
Precipitation Data Presentation on precipitation data sets |
113.48 KB | Fri 13 of Apr, 2018 | 99 |
|
|
|
4202 | |
Proposed Data Catalog Data Sets V1 Cjl 3 3 2018 Proposed Data Catalog data sets |
12.67 KB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 93 |
|
|
|
4220 | |
Proposed Data Catalog Datasets Cjl 17 4 2018 |
23.16 KB | Tue 17 of Apr, 2018 | 101 |
|
|
|
4190 | |
Roberts MDandCitation FromRDunn Temp WMO 3d What metadata are needed, and Citation issues |
418.71 KB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 99 |
|
|
|
4194 | |
Roberts SEindexing And WIS Infrastructure FromRDunn Temp WMO 4 Need for prominent discoverability of HQ Climate datasets, and use of WIS Infrastructure |
2.66 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 104 |
|
|
|
4196 | |
Robets 20180503 WIS Tb4 WMO Information System |
5.20 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 101 |
|
|
|
4106 | |
Siegmund Climate Indices Climate Indices |
517.79 KB | Wed 11 of Apr, 2018 | 99 |
|
|
|
4104 | |
Siegmund Setting Stage Maturity Models Maturity Models and need for WMO Maturity Matrix Convergence Model |
2.46 MB | Wed 11 of Apr, 2018 | 97 |
|
|
|
4156 | |
Siegmund Welcome Introduction KNMI Welcome, introduction to KNMI |
267.04 KB | Thu 12 of Apr, 2018 | 98 |
|
|
|
4108 | |
Status Of Cryospheric Data: Gaps and Challenges |
16.30 MB | Wed 11 of Apr, 2018 | 101 |
|
|
|
4176 | |
WMO 20180416 Amilan |
4.84 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 90 |
|
|
|
4192 | |
Wright Current Status Maturity Matrix Convergence Model Vs 2 Current status of the WMO Maturity Matrix Convergence Model |
534.70 KB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 98 |
|
|
|
4200 | |
Wright Trusted Climate Datasets Vs 2 Towards a process for identifying "trusted" datasets for climate purposes |
1.07 MB | Mon 16 of Apr, 2018 | 100 |
|
Venue/Hotel/Travel Information:
Venue:
Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute (KNMI)Utrechtseweg 297
3731 GA De Bilt
The Netherlands
Room:
Monday 16 AprilFahrenheitzaal (KNMI, main building, ground floor)
Tuesday 17 April
BOG A on Data Catalog: AMLS, Lanskyzaal (100 m from KNMI)
BOG B on Maturity Matrix: A1.27 (KNMI main building, 1st floor)
BOG C on Discovery&Access: A2.28 (KNMI main building, 2nd floor)
Breaks, Lunch: AMLS, Lanskyzaal
Wednesday 18 April
AMLS, Lanskyzaal
WIFI at KNMI
Netwerk = KNMI-gasten, username = WMO, password = knmiAccess to and in buildings
KNMI: use access-pass (available at KNMI front desk)AMLC: ring door bell
Contact person at KNMI:
Peter Siegmunde-mail: siegmund@knmi.nl
tel. + 31 30 2206 798
mobile: + 31 6 45832179 (within Netherlands: 06-45832179)
Hotel Information:
-Recommended hotel, closest to KNMI (1 km): https://www.biltschehoek.com/-Other hotels are in Utrecht city. The https://www.mitland.nl/ is a good second choice, relatively close
(about 3 km) to KNMI, with good bus connection to KNMI.
-If people want to stay in Utrecht city centre, there are many hotels that can be found on the Internet.
Directions:
- From Amsterdam Airport Schiphol: take a direct train to Utrecht Central Station (4 times per hours, 30’travel time)
- From Utrecht Central Station to KNMI or hotel Biltsche Hoek (15’ travel time): bus 50, 51, 52, 53, or 74,
leave at stop Tunneltje De Bilt; or take a taxi.